Skip to main content
May 21, 2025

Wood, Vinyl, or Fiber Cement Siding: Which Best Suits Historic Main Line Homes?

The Main Line, a region steeped in history and renowned for its exquisite architecture, boasts a rich tapestry of architectural styles that span centuries. From stately Colonial Revivals to elegant Victorians and charming Tudors, the Main Line’s homes stand as testaments to the area’s enduring legacy. Preserving these historic homes’ architectural integrity and timeless beauty is paramount. The choice of siding material for homes plays a pivotal role in maintaining these cherished residences’ curb appeal and historical authenticity. Selecting a siding material that harmonizes with the home’s architectural style and complements its unique character is essential to preserving its historical value and ensuring that it remains a landmark for future generations.

Siding is critical in safeguarding your home from the diverse and often harsh Pennsylvania climate: sweltering, humid summers that can warp and degrade materials to frigid, icy winters that can cause cracking and moisture infiltration.

That is where Kenny Construction Group comes in. As trusted and experienced local experts in the Main Line area, we understand the unique demands of the Pennsylvania climate and the specific needs of historic homes. We specialize in providing high-quality remodeling and siding solutions that enhance the beauty and value of your home and protect it from the elements, ensuring its longevity and structural integrity for generations to come.

Understanding the Main Line Aesthetic

Main Line homeowners face a unique challenge: selecting a siding material that provides modern benefits while preserving their homes’ historical accuracy and architectural style. Many homes in this area are prime examples of historic designs, including Georgian, Colonial Revival, and Tudor styles. These houses represent significant investments for their owners. The right siding material for homes must offer energy efficiency, durability, and weather resistance while seamlessly blending with the home’s architectural style.

Homeowners must carefully consider the visual characteristics of different siding materials, such as color, texture, and profile, to complement the unique details and proportions of their home’s architectural style. By choosing siding that respects and enhances the historic character of their homes, Main Line residents can preserve the area’s architectural heritage while enjoying the comforts of modern living.

When replacing the siding on a historic home, selecting materials and installation methods that will preserve its historical character, comply with local regulations, and ensure its long-term protection and value is crucial. First, check if your property is part of a homeowner’s association (HOA) with specific requirements for siding materials, colors, and architectural styles. Adhering to these guidelines helps maintain neighborhood consistency and property values. Pay close attention to the home’s architectural details, such as window trim, cornices, and porch railings, and choose siding materials and installation methods that complement them. Finally, select durable, low-maintenance siding materials to protect your home from the elements and reduce long-term costs.

Before and after photos of siding on house | siding material for homes | Kenny Construction Group

Factors to Consider When Choosing Siding

Vinyl siding is an affordable and low-maintenance option that resists moisture and insects; however, it can fade in sunlight and crack in cold weather. Fiber cement siding, while slightly more expensive than vinyl, offers greater durability and versatility, resisting moisture, insects, and temperature fluctuations. Pennsylvania’s varied climate makes it essential to consider these factors when choosing a siding material for homes.

Maintenance and Upkeep

Comparison chart of different siding materials for homes | Kenny Construction Group

Cost and ROI

The cost of siding materials depends on the materials used and the labor required for installation. Vinyl siding is the most economical option, while fiber cement siding occupies a middle ground in cost. Opting for high-quality siding increases property value while protecting against damage and preserving the structural integrity of the building. Selecting the appropriate siding necessitates a balanced consideration of cost, aesthetics, and long-term value.

Aesthetic Versatility

Siding materials offer diverse customization options, including color, texture, and style. Vinyl siding provides a range of colors, textures, and profiles for various aesthetic effects. Fiber cement siding offers color and texture choices, including finishes that mimic other materials, suitable for diverse architectural styles. The selection of siding material and its customization significantly impacts the aesthetic of a historic home, preserving its architectural heritage while meeting modern needs.

Vinyl Siding

Vinyl siding remains a popular choice for homeowners due to its affordability and relatively simple installation process. While it may not always be the first choice for historically accurate renovations, advancements in manufacturing techniques have created vinyl siding with textures that convincingly mimic the appearance of wood. This allows homeowners to achieve a more traditional aesthetic without the higher costs and maintenance requirements associated with natural wood siding.

Pros

Vinyl siding requires minimal upkeep, eliminating the need for frequent painting. It is also resistant to rot and insects, ensuring long-lasting protection for your home. It comes in various colors and styles, allowing you to find the perfect match for your home’s aesthetic.

Cons

Vinyl siding, while a popular choice for its affordability and versatility, can present challenges when applied to historic Main Line homes. Improper installation can lead to warping, cracking, or other damage over time, compromising the home’s aesthetic and structural integrity. While technological advances have led to vinyl siding options that mimic the look of wood or other traditional materials, careful consideration is necessary to ensure that the chosen style complements the home’s architectural details and historical context.

Cost and Installation

Vinyl siding is affordable, but proper installation by a qualified contractor is essential. If it is installed incorrectly, it will bubble because the material expands due to the changes in weather in Pennsylvania.

Fiber Cement Siding

James Hardie fiber cement siding is a durable and versatile solution for homeowners. Made of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers, it resists rot, insects, fire, and moisture damage, unlike wood siding. James Hardie siding is available in various colors, textures, and styles; it mimics the look of wood, stucco, or brick. It is low-maintenance, requiring only periodic cleaning. Overall, James Hardie fiber cement siding is a beautiful, durable, and easy-to-maintain choice for homeowners looking to enhance their home’s value.

Pros

James Hardie siding is durable, low-maintenance, and available in many styles, making it a valuable investment that can enhance any home’s curb appeal and value.

Cons

  • Higher installation cost due to specialized skills required
  • Heavier weight necessitates an experienced crew, increasing labor costs
  • Improper installation can lead to moisture damage
  • Requires periodic maintenance, including repainting and resealing
  • Potential for longer lead times
Photo of house with James Hardie fiber cement siding

Cost and Installation

Professional installation is essential for fiber cement siding’s longevity and effectiveness. Improper installation can lead to cracking and void warranties. While the initial cost may be higher, its durability and low maintenance make it cost-effective in the long run. Fiber cement siding can increase resale value, offering a return on investment.

Which Siding Material is Best for Your Main Line Home?

When choosing siding for a historic Main Line home, consider historical accuracy, maintenance requirements, and financial implications.

For exterior renovations, check with your local historical commission or HOA for any restrictions on siding materials for homes. Choose a siding that complements the neighborhood’s look and feel. For historic homes, consult a local designer for appropriate siding choices.

Why Choose Kenny Construction Group

The team at Kenny Construction Group receives annual James Hardie training and has spent the last decade installing James Hardie siding throughout the Main Line. We would love to provide you with your dream home!

Our commitment to excellence shines through in every project we undertake. We source only the finest materials, ensuring that your siding looks beautiful and stands the test of time. Our team of skilled craftsmen takes pride in their meticulous installation methods, paying close attention to every detail to deliver a flawless finish. This dedication to quality craftsmanship guarantees the longevity of your siding and your ultimate satisfaction with the results.

At Kenny Construction Group, selecting the right siding for your historic Main Line home is a personal journey. We work closely with each homeowner, taking the time to understand your vision, aesthetic preferences, and the unique architectural features of your home. Our team of experts is always ready to answer your questions, offer practical advice, and guide you through the decision-making process. Consider us your friendly and knowledgeable neighbor, here to help you make the best choice for your home’s exterior. We will provide tailored recommendations, considering historical accuracy, energy efficiency, durability, and budget. We aim to ensure you are delighted with the siding solution we deliver, enhancing the beauty and value of your historic Main Line home for generations to come.

Contact Kenny Construction Group for Your Historic Home Siding Solutions!

In summary, the key takeaway is to emphasize that the choice of siding for a historic Main Line home should not be taken lightly. Selecting a siding material for homes that not only preserves and enhances the home’s historical character and architectural integrity but also offers practical benefits is vital. These benefits include durability against the specific weather conditions of the Main Line region and fitting within the homeowner’s budgetary constraints.

If you want a qualified contractor to provide open communication and top-quality craftsmanship, call Kenny Construction Group for your free estimate! Our team of experts understands the unique challenges and considerations of preserving the historic charm of Main Line homes. We are committed to providing practical, trustworthy advice and top-quality craftsmanship that will stand the test of time. We are always happy to chat and provide the information you need to make informed decisions about your home improvement project.